Are menthol cigarettes which account for one quarter of U.S. cigarette sales more addictive than other smokes? That’s a top question facing the FDA’s new advisory committee on tobacco regulation, which is meeting for the first time Tuesday. It’s tasked with determining whether menthols should be treated differently from regular tobacco.

After Congress shifted the authority to regulate tobacco products to the Food and Drug Administration, one of its first actions was to ban clove, cinnamon and other candy flavored cigarettes. It was a small market, and the cigarettes were sold primarily to young people.

Matthew Myers of the Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids says it was easy for the FDA to ban the candy flavored tobacco.

“The products it banned had very few users and no sustained users,” he says, “so it wasn’t concerned about what would happen if you instantly withdrew them.”

On the other hand, millions of Americans buy menthol cigarettes, which make up more than one fourth of the industry’s $70 billion in sales.

In fact, a recent survey showed that nearly half of teenagers light up a menthol when they start to smoke. And it’s not just teenagers 75 percent of black smokers, compared with 25 percent of white smokers, prefer menthol.

“What we aren’t certain of Is it because menthol makes it easier to smoke because it coats your throat, or is there some other reason?” Myers says. “The advantage to FDA looking at this is that they will examine the science in its totality and give us an answer to that question once and for all.”

There are studies that show that African Americans tend to smoke fewer cigarettes yet suffer more smoking related health problems, and have greater difficulty in quitting. Historical documents show that the African American community was in fact targeted by the industry.

Congress ordered the new Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee to study marketing, addiction and health effects to determine whether menthol should be treated differently from regular tobacco. There’s a 180 page list of studies that committee members will have a chance to discuss over the next two days. They’ll find there is very little consensus.

“It’s a very subtle issue,” says Andrew Hyland of the Roswell Park Cancer Institute in Buffalo, N.Y. He followed 13,000 smokers for five years to see whether menthol made cigarettes more addictive, for example. He found no difference between menthol and regular cigarettes.

“The products themselves are engineered to be addictive and to suck money out of their consumers’ pockets, basically,” Hyland says. The menthol, he concluded, was just a marketing tool.

“Does it have an extra addictive effect? Perhaps it does, but the answer to that question is fundamentally not that important relative to the broader issue of why is menthol in these products to begin with?” Hyland says. “It’s no different than putting cinnamon flavor in products to make them more attractive to would be smokers.”

Oddly enough, Hyland’s study is cited by the tobacco industry because he found that regular and menthol smokers quit at about the same rate.

Lorillard Tobacco Co. makes Newport, which has the largest share of the market. Lorillard said in a written statement that menthol has been used for decades in food, drink, cosmetics and other products. And a spokesman for Philip Morris, the maker of Marlboro menthols, Parliaments and Virginia Slims, says any decision about menthol should be science based.

This week’s meeting is just a start. This summer, the advisory committee will review industry documents to see what’s in menthol cigarettes, something no one outside the industry has had complete access to before now.

Cigarettes and tobacco disappear from supermarket displays from today

Discovery health “10 little-known facts about e-cigarettes”
MORE DON’T MISS

  • Mother and me time Katherine Heigl enjoys a glass of wine as she chats to her mum Nancy on a girls’ lunch date in New York Quality time
  • Not quite Marky Mark! Justin Bieber flashes his Calvin Kleins after an all nighter in the recording studio Can’t top Walhberg’s old Calvin Klein advert
  • Chanel Iman flashes the flesh in tiny crocheted minidress as she’s pictured with fianc A$AP Rocky for first time since their engagement
  • Nothing scary about this body! Spice Girl Mel B shows off the results of her twerking work out in a sizzling bikini selfie Week of intense twerking paid off
  • Forget Divergent, that’s distracting! Shailene Woodley reveals glimpse of her midriff in luxe leather pleated skirt and top at MTV Movie Awards
  • They make being vegan look great! Jenna Dewan Tatum and Kate Mara enjoy a girls’ night out at celebrity hotspot Crossroads
  • Bumping along nicely Drew Barrymore shows off her pregnancy glow on lunch date Keeping herself busy out about town
  • She’ll be sitting on the sidelines! Kendra Wilkinson displays heavily pregnant belly while taking her son to soccer Looked ready to pop
  • When in Rome! Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield go sightseeing on a Vespa in break from promoting Spider Man 2 Sightseeing in Rome
  • It’s amore! Natalie Portman and husband Benjamin Millepied are bitten by the Venice bug as they return for a romantic break Strolling arm in arm
  • Next stop Broadway? Simon Cowell’s X Factor musical comedy I Can’t Sing! may be headed to New York theatre And a TV version could be in the works, too
  • Like father, like son! Kai Rooney out runs mother Coleen in a move footballer dad Wayne would be proud of Eldest son of Premiere League footballer Wayne
  • Looks like talent runs in the family! Miley Cyrus shares videos of herself and little sister Noah dancing together The former Disney star shared two videos
  • Gisele Bundchen audited by IRS after being named top earning supermodel in Forbes for seventh year running Day before taxes due
  • She means business! US TV presneter Giuliana Rancic arrives in Australia wearing statement suit Mother of one makes rare trip Down Under
  • Raising the bra! Former TOWIE star Georgina Dorsett cements her super WAG status as she hits the town in a VERY daring cropped lace bustier
  • ‘It’s cheesy, but I’m still so proud!’ Jessica Mauboy’s excitement as she gears up for Eurovision performance Aussie singer will be a guest performer
  • Ready, set smooch! Dianna Agron gets VERY up close and personal with new actor beau Thomas Cocquerel at Coachella Spotted smooching
  • She did it! Amy Willerton looks relieved as she completes the 2014 London Marathon in just over six hours Looked delighted as she crossed the line
  • ‘We pray to the risen Jesus’ U2’s Bono reveals he worships with his family on a giant bed Says he gets his inner strength from Jesus
  • New mother Teresa Palmer slips back into a swimsuit for pool fun with her husband Australian actress gave birth to son Bodhi in February
  • Forever beautiful How to glow after 50 How do you tackle the issue of fake tan darkening age spots on your face? Elsa McAlonan advises
  • Pictured Conan O’Brien and Ellie Goulding fine tune their performances as they rehearse for MTV Movie Awards Just hours ’til show
  • Always a wild child? A teenage Cara Delevingne is pictured larking around as she smokes a suspicious looking cigarette A very large roll up
  • Bits and pieces The products that will make your week Bits and pieces brings you the best products from this week.
  • PICTURE EXCLUSIVE Adrienne Maloof throws extravagant birthday party for her eight year old twin boys And it was drama free!
  • Pink looks fit and toned as she soaks up the sun in a white two piece bikini during Mexican getaway She’s certain to get an even tan…
  • Good HEIR(ess) day! Tamara Ecclestone and husband Jay Rutland enjoy afternoon out in London with baby Sophia ‘born to be a mother’
  • SEBASTIAN SHAKESPEARE Irving goes to war over the Fuhrer’s missing hair Repeated requests for return of the hair used in last week’s episode
  • ‘Get back to the jungle where you belong’ My racist abuse growing up in Cornwall, by Hollywood star Thandie Newton Grew up in Penzance
  • Ginnifer Goodwin shows off her pregnancy figure in skinny jeans as she steps out with new husband Josh Dallas for first time after wedding
  • Desert dazzle! Kate Bosworth is blooming lovely in floral keyhole dress at Coachella before partying the night away in boho frock Partying with her hubby
  • Party of two! Shanae Grimes and husband Josh Beech can’t keep their hands off each other as they pile on the PDA at Coachella The celeb studded event
  • Fast lady of motorsports commentary Melanie Sykes picks up something petit and perky to zip around in Her super mini drop top
  • A tale of two (revealing) outfits Rose McGowan swaps tight black tank dress for midriff baring crop top at Coachella festival Showed off toned midriff
  • Blondes do have more fun! Vanessa Hudgens debuts dyed ‘mermaid hair’ as she hits Coachella in bikini top and tiny denim shorts With beau Austin Butler
  • Ellen Page wears a sharp suit and tie as she credits transgender actress Laverne Cox for giving her the courage to come out as a lesbian at GLAAD Awards
  • That’s not very Bright! Returning TOWIE star Lydia Rose shows off her bra in revealing semi sheer top as she hits the club Made a dramatic return
  • New romance alert! Zoe Kravitz strolls through Coachella festival holding hands holds hands with bearded mystery man Who’s the mystery man?
  • Cruz control Fitness mad David Beckham is joined by his youngest son as he pays ANOTHER visit to the gym Like father, like son
  • ‘She’s living through me’ Peaches Geldof opened up on ‘traumatic’ childhood and grieving for her late mother Paula Yates just weeks before tragic death
  • Iggy goes ziggy(zag) Miss Azalea dons patterned hot pants and a black leather crop for fashion event at Coachella Performing at festival
  • No wonder she’s her style critic! Kate Moss enjoys a family lunch with effortlessly chic daughter Lila Grace and rocker husband Jamie Hince
  • Women obsessed with age, weight and appearance need to get a life, claims actress Helen McCrory Such women have ‘too much time on hands’
  • Britain certainly has Got Talent! BGT returns with its highest viewing figures EVER as 11.1 million fans tune in Series eight got under way on Saturday night
  • ‘We’re looking at castles’ Australian singer Ricki Lee Coulter reveals plans for a wedding in France… and why she’s NOT having any bridesmaids
  • Kym Marsh wears classically styled LBD as she steps out on towering heels for night out with older sister Tracey Every bit the soap queen
  • Sister act! The Face Australia star Cheyenne Tozzi and sibling Tahyna’s LA jam session One is one of Aussie’s top models, the other’s an actress and director
  • David McIntosh accused of flirting with porn star behind Kelly Brook’s back… as ex girlfriend claims he cheated on her ‘six times’
  • ‘I think about it every day!’ Busty model Kate Upton wants ‘smaller boobs’… but insists she’s proud of her curvy size 10 frame Open to breast reduction
  • Goth no more? Lorde rocks out at Coachella in a cleanly pressed all white ensemble… but keeps her trademark burgundy lipstick On outdoor stage
  • ‘Live television is very strenuous’ Sir Bruce Forsyth, 86, reveals he quit Strictly Come Dancing because it was affecting his health Took its toll
  • Some things never change! Katie Price shares snaps of baby Jett’s first holiday… and some racier ones Tanning herself in a very fluorescent bikini!
  • It costs less than a cappuccino. So does the High Street’s new low budget frock look (and feel) as cheap as the price tag? We try on the sell out f1.99 dress
  • Where there’s a WILL there’s a way Amy Willerton limbers up as she leads the celebrity runners at the 2014 London Marathon In high spirits
  • Cooking up wedding plans! My Kitchen Rules’ Chloe counting down to New York nuptials… and Kelly is a bridesmaid
  • A little ray of sunshine Amy Childs steps out in structured yellow mini dress from her own range as she pays a visit to Essex boutique Her own design
  • Fraulein Lott hits the slopes! Pixie slips into sexy lederhosen and goes incognito in a scarlet wig as she parties at Snowbombing with Oliver Cheshire
  • As Long As You Love Me! Backstreet Boys star Nick Carter marries Lauren Kitt… but younger brother Aaron doesn’t make it Santa Barbara ceremony
  • Not quite festival fashion David! Hasselhoff, 61, tries to keep up with the hip Coachella kids, but falls flat with bum bag, loafers and white shirt
  • He’s The Biggest Loser! Craig crowned king of slim after losing almost 80kg… and now he’s found love too The heaviest in Biggest Loser Australia
  • ‘We’re overwhelmed with love!’ My Kitchen Rules’ Pete Evans engaged to swimsuit model after surprise New York proposal His impromptu proposal
  • CHRISTOPHER STEVENS ON WEEKEND’S TV There’s life in us oldies yet… just ask a playboy bunny Old ‘uns would win hands down
  • The night of little black dresses Paula Abdul and Jane Seymour stun on the red carpet as they attend the Ballet Gala Touch of glamour
  • ‘I feel like a new woman’ Lara Bingle jets back to Sydney with short and sweet haircut after Hollywood jaunt Arrived back in Australia with a new look
  • He’ll make a fine house husband! Jason Dundas gets his hands dirty in the kitchen in a shirtless snap Australian presenter gets the marigolds on
  • My turn to shine! Sofia Richie, 15, displays her chic style at Coachella… as older sister Nicole Richie, 32, lays low in Studio City
  • Australian socialite Brynne Edelsten kisses her new guy… while ex Geoffrey moves on too with another buxom young blonde She’s moving on
  • ‘It was very hard to lose weight and keep it off’ Sally Obermeder reveals she tipped the scales at 90kg before launching TV career
  • Fashion comes before the music! Victoria’s Secret model Shanina Shaik wears THREE outfits in one day as she parties with friends at Coachella
  • Shirtless Desperate Housewives star Jesse Metcalfe shows off his buff body as he and bikini clad fianc e Cara Santana soak up the sun at Coachella pool party
  • Alexander Wang will create a collection for H&M, designer confirms today New York based creative director for Balenciaga announced the venture
  • Kendall and Kylie take Koachella! Jenner sisters show their darker side dressed in black for the second night of music festival Catwalk… or party?
  • Model mayhem! Poppy Delevingne joins sister Cara and Sienna Miller for day two of her Coachella hen do Poppy, 27, hosted a Coachella brunch
  • Silver surfer! Dennis Quaid rolls back the years as he goes shirtless and shows off his toned abs… one day after his 60th birthday Looking good for his age
  • Beyonce shocks fans as she makes a surprise appearance at Coachella for a playful rendition of Losing You with sister Solange Jamming in the desert
  • Britain’s Got Talent’s dancing gran hits back in ‘fakery’ row as she dedicates her jaw dropping routine to her late husband Previously won in Spain
  • ‘I nearly died but I didn’t care’ Lily Allen reveals she nearly lost her life as she opens up about tragic miscarriage for the first time Lost a child in 2010
  • She’s definitely not chilled out! Saoirse Ronan rugs up with a giant coat and hot water bottle on the set of her film Brooklyn In Dublin
  • Feeling lonely? 50 Cent shares throwback selfies with some of the world’s most beautiful women… including Kim Kardashian and Beyonce
  • Margot Robbie legs it to a London tattoo parlour in ripped denim hot pants The Wold Of Wall Street star channelled her inner beach babe
  • A chip off(side) the old block Proud new father Theo Walcott shares first picture of son Finley Wife Melanie Slade gave birth on Thursday to littlest Gunner
  • Supermodel Jon K smoulders at AW14 catwalk showcase for affordable clothing label F&F F&F’s come a long way from the supermarket
  • ‘It’s eating a prawn!’ A hysterical Ruby Rose calls for backup as she encounters a stray possum on her dining room table Unexpected house guest
  • Alessandra Ambrosio shows off her svelte physique in bustier and hotpants as she dances her heart out at Coachella Victoria’s Secret Angel
  • She’s nailed it! Christine Bleakley steps out for a well deserved manicure TV presenter and WAG so she knows about keeping up appearance
  • Olivia Fane’s mother, 77, was sinking deeper into dementia, refused to eat and asked to die if she became ‘severely disabled’ Here’s why letting her end her life was her ‘final act of love’
  • Booty full escape! Kim Kardashian shows off her incredible figure in yoga tights and knee high boots for a flight out of town Oooh la la
  • Reese Witherspoon displays her Bahamas tan in aqua shorts and matching trainers as she goes for a jog after family vacation Keep fit start to weekend
  • Gotta have Faith? Flame haired Paloma ‘is surprise contender for X Factor judging role’… as Kesha is also thrown into the mix Under consideration
  • Monochrome mum to be Kimberley Walsh displays growing tum in spotty jumpsuit as she enjoys comedy show with pal Denise Van Outen
  • He needs the caffeine hit! Chris Hemsworth stocks up on iced coffee three weeks after the birth of his twin boys Wife Elsa Pataky gave birth to Tristan & Sasha